Toxic Fans Cost Trophies - Science Proves It

Toxic Spurs fans are not helping the club one little bit, they are damaging trophy chances

The Science Behind How Toxic Support Undermines a Winning Mentality

There’s a strong body of research showing that repeated exposure to negativity...

Especially online...

Has measurable effects on people’s mental health and mindset.

Spurs fans take note.

Your actions affect performance, points, trophies.

Science says so.

You DO NOT know better.

Tottenham Hotspur have reached six finals under Daniel Levy.

We have won just one.

While many fans pin the blame on the board...

The managers...

The Chairman...

The owners...

And even individual players...

There’s an uncomfortable truth that needs to be said:

Some of the blame belongs to the fans.

Not the ones (generally) who travel up and down the country.

Not the ones who believe in the team...

Even when it hurts...

But the loudest ones on X.

The ones poisoning the atmosphere before a ball is even kicked.

Social Media Has Made It Easy to Criticise. Too Easy.

Spend five minutes on X (formerly Twitter) after a bad result, and you’ll see it:

Mind you, you'll see it after good results...

You'll see it before games...

You'll see it during international breaks.

• “He’s finished.”

• "He's useless."

• “We’ll never win with this lot.”

• "Why did we buy him."

• “Another bottle job.”

These come from accounts suggesting they are Spurs supporters.

But there’s nothing supportive about it.

It’s fake to sing for 90 minutes when you’ve been abusing the players online all week.

Mind you, against Chelsea they weren't even doing that were they.

They were booing a substitution.

They were chanting you don't know what you're doing to Ange Postecoglou.

All while pretending they wanted Tottenham Hotspur to win.

They put negativity in the players minds all week...

Then negativity during a game...

And claim to be supporting...

Claim to be supporters.

It’s fake to post “COYS” after spending the week tearing them down.

And here’s the thing nobody wants to admit:

This constant negativity could be one of the reasons Tottenham aren’t winning trophies.

🧠 The Psychological Evidence: Negativity Destroys Performance

It’s not just “soft” to talk about feelings.

It’s science.

And when you're trying to win under pressure...

Your mindset isn't a bonus...

It's the foundation of elite performance.

Let me repeat that...

MINDSET is the FOUNDATION of elite performance.

If you are posting

Let’s start with the facts.

🧪 1. Negativity Bias: Why the Worst Comments Stick

Humans are hardwired to remember pain.

Psychologists call it the negativity bias... 

The tendency to focus more on criticism than praise.

📚 Baumeister et al. (2001) found that negative interactions are five times more powerful than positive ones.

So when a player sees “You’re not good enough” on Monday…

Then “You cost us that game” on Wednesday…

No amount of “COYS” on Saturday is going to balance that out.

The damage is already done.

You are damaging the team...

The players...

The performance...

The results...

The club.

If you're doing more damage than good...

Then that's evidence...

That you're 'support' needs to change.

💭 2. Emotional Contagion: Negativity Spreads

A 2014 study published in PNAS showed that emotions spread on social media like viruses.

Negative posts led to more negative posts —...

And more negative moods.

If that’s what’s in a player’s feed before a game, guess what they absorb?

Not belief.

Not trust.

Not unity.

Not positivity.

But Fear. Doubt. Pressure.

🧱 3. Mental Load & Rumination

Negativity doesn’t just hurt...

It lingers.

When players ruminate — replaying criticism in their minds...

They burn mental energy that should be focused on performance.

🔥 Dr. Sian Beilock, a leading performance psychologist, proved that under pressure...

Even the most talented athletes choke...

When their minds are cluttered with fear or self-consciousness.

Where does that fear often come from?

Public judgement.

Abuse.

Being told: “You’re not a winner.”

In other words...

All the negativity you post about them...

The team...

The manager...

The club.

💥 4. Self-Fulfilling Prophecies

Tell someone they’ll bottle it enough times… 

And they’ll start to believe it.

It becomes a mental script.

That script plays out in the tunnel before a game...

Before a final.

It shapes body language...

Focus...

Risk-taking.

And sometimes...

It decides the game before it’s begun.

🎙️ Real-World Quotes: What Players Say About Fan Abuse

We like to think of footballers as unshakable.

Millionaires. Protected. Professionals.

But here’s the truth: they see everything.

And it affects them more than fans want to admit.

🗣️ Ben Davies (Spurs, speaking in 2021):

“It does affect you.
You can get 100 nice messages, but it’s always the one negative one that sticks.”

🗣️ Eric Dier, after confronting a fan in the stands in 2020:

“I had enough.
My family was there and people were abusing them and me.
There’s a line and it was crossed.”

🗣️ Dele Alli (now open about his mental health struggles):

“We’re human beings. It’s easy to forget that when you're behind a screen...
People don’t see the damage it can do.”

He’s not the only one.

🗣️ Granit Xhaka (Arsenal, former captain):

“I felt very alone.
The abuse was overwhelming… they said they wanted my daughter to get cancer.
I lost my love for the game.”

🧠 These aren’t isolated moments — they’re symptoms of a culture.

A culture where fans mistake “passion” for permission to destroy.

A culture where one bad performance = “get out of my club.”

A culture where players are expected to give everything for a badge...

While being told they’re failures...

By the very people who claim to support them!

Footballers are trained to handle pressure.

They’re not trained to handle thousands of hate-filled messages disguised as “banter.”

And when that noise gets loud before an important game...

Don’t be surprised when belief drains from the team.

Because you have caused it.

🧠 The Mindset of Serial Winners vs Serial Doubters

If you want to understand why some clubs lift trophies...

And others fall short...

Don’t just look at the tactics.

Look at the mentality...

Not just of the players... 

But the fans.

Because winners think differently.

We speak differently.

We support differently.

🔥 Serial Winners: They Back Through Belief

Look at fans of clubs who win consistently.

There’s a defiance to them. A unity.

Even when things are going wrong...

They back their team with belief...

Not bitterness.

Liverpool are famous for it.

Their fans believe they can make a difference.

Ours don't.

🗣️ “We’ll find a way.”
🗣️ “Let’s lift them.”
🗣️ “This is where we stand tall.”

They’re not naive.

They’re invested in winning.

They understand that belief is part of the formula.

And when you carry that into games — it’s powerful.

💣 Serial Doubters: They Back with Conditions

Now look at the doubters.

Look at Spurs fans.

The ones who hammer players online all week...

Then post “Come on you Spurs” at kickoff like nothing happened.

🗣️ “We always bottle it.”
🗣️ “This team’s weak.”
🗣️ “He’s a fraud.”

This isn’t constructive criticism.

It’s a mindset of sabotage disguised as passion.

And it creates a culture where everyone’s waiting to say “I told you so”...instead of “We believe in you.”

That energy seeps in.

It creates tension.

And it kills momentum.

Tottenham Hotspur have had world-class players...

Elite coaches...

And incredible moments.

But how many times have we entered a final with a united front between fans and team?

How many times has the support been filled with genuine belief…
...instead of hesitation?

It’s not about pretending everything is perfect.

It’s about recognising that the mindset of the supporters matters.

Let's look at some takeaways.

📌 Key Psychological Effects of Online Negativity

1. Emotional Contagious Disease

A groundbreaking study by Kramer et al. (2014) published in PNAS showed that emotional content spreads on social media — and not just consciously. 

People exposed to more negative content are more likely to post negative updates themselves.
👉 This means negativity from fans literally infects the emotional state of others, including players.

2. Negativity Bias & Mental Load

Humans are hardwired to pay more attention to negative information — it's called the negativity bias. This means one abusive comment outweighs dozens of supportive ones.

🧠 Repeated exposure to criticism increases stress, lowers motivation and leads to rumination — the repetitive focusing on negative thoughts — which is a risk factor for anxiety and depression.

3. Toxic Social Media and Depression

A 2018 Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology study (Hunt et al.) found that reducing social media usage led to significant declines in depression and loneliness.

🎯 The link was strongest in people exposed to hostile or critical environments — much like footballers reading hate-filled comments after a loss.

⚽️ Footballers and Abuse: The Direct Link

The Professional Footballers’ Association (PFA) and Kick It Out have both published reports showing:

• A rise in racial abuse, performance abuse and personal threats on X/Twitter.

• Many players feel discouraged or lose focus after reading online hate — even when they try to “stay off it.”

One anonymous Premier League player said:

“You try not to look, but you do. And when you do, even after a win, someone finds something bad to say. It sticks in your head. You overthink everything.”

🧠 Scientific Conclusion: Negativity Weakens Mental Resilience

Chronic exposure to toxic feedback:

• Undermines confidence and self-efficacy

• Increases fear of failure

• Shifts mindset from growth to self-preservation

This is the opposite of what elite performance environments need.

💥 If You Really Want to Win… Change How You Support

Tottenham Hotspur do not lack talent.

They do not lack infrastructure.

They do not lack ambition.

Regardless of negative what agenda-driven fans think.

But far too often…

The club lack the energy of belief behind them.

And that's your fault.

Finals aren’t just won on the pitch.

They’re won in the buildup.

In the training ground.

In the tunnel.

And...

Whether fans like it or not...

In the atmosphere created by the people who claim to support the club.

You can’t spend five days planting seeds of doubt...

And expect flowers of victory to bloom on the sixth.

🚫 Enough with the fake support.

If you’ve spent the week mocking...

Criticising...

Or abusing your own players online...

You’re not a supporter.

You’re a spectator of failure... 

Waiting for it to happen so you can be proven right.

That’s not love.

That’s ego.

✅ Real support is unconditional belief with standards.

Yes, demand more.

Yes, call for improvements.

But do it from a place of wanting the team to rise...

Not tear them down.

Frame it in a positive message...

Not a negative message.

Support is a force multiplier — but only if it’s real.

Only if it’s loud when it matters.

Only if it’s present before kickoff...

Not just after a goal...

In essence.

So next time a game comes around, ask yourself this:

"Am I helping to lift this team… or am I one of the weights they're dragging behind them?"

Because belief doesn’t guarantee trophies.

But doubt?

Doubt guarantees failure.

And after five failed finals out of six under Daniel Levy...

Maybe it’s time to realise the players aren’t the only ones underperforming.

Proper Supporters Support

“Share this post if you believe in true support”

COYS

​